A tale of two train stations
May. 8th, 2009 11:29 pmNew York City of course has two major train stations these days. Pennsylvania Station handles all Amtrak service in and out of New York, plus New Jersey Transit and the Long Island Railroad; Grand Central Terminal, historically the stomping grounds of the New York Central and New York, New Haven, and Hartford railroads, is the Manhattan end of Metro-North trains. Of these the Metro-North commuters by far get the better deal.
Grand Central has an outpost of the New York transit museum (more a gift shop with a small exhibit space) and I took some time there to look around. My first thought was that it could reasonably compete in the "Classy European Railway Stations" competition: several concourses filled with little shops, a small grocery, lots of granite and marble, pleasantly art-deco ticket windows, and so on. There's a downstairs level with lots of fast food options, and a restaurant on the main concourse. I did eventually find the transit museum outpost, which was worth the visit if not huge.
I then bopped over on the Ⓢ train to Times Square (very strong signs that there used to be a 4-track connection between the Times Square shuttle and the 7th Avenue IRT line) and took a ① to Penn Station. You might notice peering at my Flickr that there are no pictures of Penn Station. From the concourse this is basically three stations. The NJ Transit area is somewhat nice but has few amenities. The Amtrak station seemed to redecorate aiming for "sterile" and got "vaguely oppressive". The Long Island Railroad section is dark, and crowded, and generally not a place you really feel like hanging out. (And it's a good demonstration that just because you put shops and restaurants in a place it doesn't mean it's attractive.)
Because I could, I took LIRR out to Queens. The trains were quite comfortable, and felt oddly larger than typical MBTA stock. Seeing real position-light signals in action was a little strange, but (after some deciphering) there they were and they seemed to be showing reasonable things. It was a pretty fast, pretty smooth ride out, not a bad way to go if that's what your commute winds up being...just with that horrible station at the inbound end.